The request should have been a simple one: find the lost music, return it. But my sister counted the cost on the backs of her fingers like a debt collector.
Her answer did not comfort me. It did not have to; it simply confirmed an old suspicion that had been settling like dust at the base of my ribs for years. She had never looked ordinary for long. When we were children she could coax frogs from the lake by whistling. As teenagers she would stitch light into the hems of coats so we would have a place to warm our hands on cold nights. She read maps of the city and could tell by the pattern of cracks in the pavement where a coin was buried. People called such things eccentric or talented. I called them clues.
"She remembers," he said to me then. "She remembers being someone else. She remembers names that weren't hers. She does this at night. She calls them by the wrong mouth. And when she does, I feel it—like something is taking from me."
"Because someone must be willing to take what breaks and make it less sharp," she said. "Because mercy is work, and it must be done by someone who knows the price."